Old Sarge's Bar

Located in the heart of McCook, Nebraska, Old Sarge's Bar is a quintessential small-town bar & grill that embodies the charm and character only a local favorite can offer. Far from pretentious or flashy, this unassuming spot prides itself on delivering a genuine experience where good drinks, solid company, and friendly faces reign supreme.

The bar’s beverage lineup is thoughtfully curated, with staples like Bud Lite and Miller Lite on tap alongside a rotating selection of craft beers that keep things fresh for regulars and newcomers alike. Their Bloody Mary has earned a special nod among patrons—sturdy, flavorful, and perfectly suited for those looking to sip on something with a little kick. For those craving a simple, nostalgic snack, the Peanut Butter Crackers add a comforting, salty-sweet crunch that pairs beautifully with a cold drink.

More than just a place to quench your thirst, Old Sarge's offers engaging entertainment options that make each visit unique. Pool tables—both in the main area and tucked away in a quieter back room—invite friendly competition, while the TouchTunes jukebox ensures the soundtrack suits every mood. The presence of keno and pickle tickets sprinkled throughout adds an exciting element of chance, proudly illustrated by stories of lucky patrons hitting it big.

But what truly sets Old Sarge's apart is its welcoming atmosphere. Customers repeatedly praise the attentive and helpful bartenders who go beyond pouring drinks, often sharing insider tips on where to find great local eats or simply chatting in a way that makes you feel like part of the community. Whether you’re squeezing in a quick drink, catching a casual game of pool, or relaxing on the comfy smoking patio, it feels like stepping into a space where people genuinely enjoy each other's company without any pretense.

Melissa Schlup captured the spirit well, highlighting the bartender’s warmth and helpfulness even when not dining here. Meanwhile, Erin Schwing-Sines noted the lively but comfortable crowd, the satisfying pizza, and the sense of small-town camaraderie that makes Old Sarge’s more than just a bar—it’s a cornerstone of local life. Keith James’s return visit proved that the quality and atmosphere remain consistently inviting, earning a well-deserved five-star review. And Bruce Wailes’s reflections on the bar’s authenticity perfectly sum up its enduring appeal: a place that knows who it is, embraces its imperfections, and welcomes you like an old friend.

If you find yourself in McCook craving a solid drink, a bit of luck, and a genuine slice of Nebraskan nightlife, Old Sarge's Bar is where you want to be. It’s not about glitz or glamor—it's about real people, real stories, and a down-to-earth experience that leaves you feeling right at home.